Blog

Hougan: ETFs Aren’t Ruining EMs

By
Matt Hougan
February 04, 2014
Share:

Related ETFs

Ticker Fund name
IEMGiShares Core MSCI Emerging Markets
Related ETF Lists
Emerging Markets ETFs

The FT’s recent article on emerging markets and ETFs raises interesting points … if only they were true.

The Financial Times has a thing about exchange-traded funds. I can’t quite figure out why, but for whatever reason, the great newspaper—perhaps my favorite—consistently attacks ETFs.

Net-net it’s a good thing. The FT’s journalists are among the best in the world, and their persistent probing has forced ETF investors to look hard at the structure.

But sometimes they aim … and miss … and the results can lead investors astray. John Authers’ recent column on emerging markets falls into this camp.

Authers’ piece, titled “Emerging Markets Are Badly Served By ETFs,” claims that by allowing investors to buy and sell emerging market ETFs, they have ruined emerging market economies.

“The raw facts are that a remarkable amount of money has been pulled out of EM with indecent haste; and that this was the first emerging market sell-off to be conducted mostly through ETFs,” wrote Authers.

“They have misallocated capital, and helped to create yet another boom and bust cycle for the emerging world when many countries had fixed deep-seated institutional problems. There are better ways to invest in emerging markets than through ETFs,” he added.

Authers’ piece is riddled with confusing and contradictory statistics. For instance, he cites Morgan Stanley data saying that ETFs “account for about $330 billion of the $1.3 trillion in emerging market equities.”

That would be a frightening number, suggesting that ETFs hold about 25 percent of all emerging market stocks.

But hold on a second. Two paragraphs later, Authers cites TrimTabs data saying that “emerging market ETFs suffered redemptions of $4.4 billion (4.8 percent of their assets) last week.”

It’s not clear how $4.4 billion is 4.8 percent of $330 billion.

(Our data suggest U.S. investors have $117 billion invested in emerging market equity ETFs, by the way.)

Worse than the percentage confusion is Morgan Stanley’s $1.3 trillion estimate for the total capitalization of emerging market stocks. MSCI—the world’s leading global index firm—puts the number at $3.7 trillion.

If you use the MSCI number, the $4.4 billion that flew out of emerging market ETFs last week represented about 0.11 percent of the total amount of money invested in emerging markets. That doesn’t sound scary at all. In fact, that sounds fairly conservative for a market that’s in the midst of a panic.

 

ETF DAILY DATA

The oil funds 'XOP' and 'OIH' gathered money on Thursday, April 16, helping lift total U.S.-listed ETF assets to a record $2.158 trillion.

'SPY,' 'LNK' and 'XOP' paced SSgA's issuer-leader inflows on Thursday, April 16, as total U.S.-listed ETF assets reached a record $2.158 trillion.

ETF.COM ANALYST BLOGS

By Olivier Ludwig

If you’re puzzled by Israel’s relatively strong stock market performance, don’t forget you’re taking measure of a developed country.

By Olivier Ludwig

If only Fidelity could speak freely about all the positive things it does for investors.

By Dave Nadig

Last week’s minor information hiccup had huge implications.

By Dave Nadig

How Ric Edelman is reinventing the ‘new economy’ investing paradigm.