Blog

Nadig: Rethinking Investment Performance

By
Dave Nadig
June 25, 2014
Share:

What the best-performing fund is may be the most expensive question in investing—especially for financial advisors.

Recently, two things came across my desk that made me think we need a radical redefinition of what "performance" means for financial advisors and their clients.

The first was the launch of Covestor's free ETF portfolios. Last week, the advisory firm waded into the model portfolio business with a set of three ETF portfolios which, with a minimum of $10,000, they will manage for free.

The second was two pieces of research from State Street Global Advisors, one on how advisors and clients see each other, the second proposing a personalized model of performance analysis drawn from the sovereign wealth fund world.

Both of these suggest we're living in an odd, odd world. It's a world in which there's not only a disconnect between where investors are finding and perceiving value, but a disconnect between investor expectations of what they can get from an advisor, and how the real world works.

Let's start with the Covestor announcement.

I'm all about people seeing how easy it is to build a low-cost ETF portfolio. After all, Matt Hougan puts one together every year and spends the rest of the year crowing about it. The issue is simply one of caveat emptor.

If someone is reading Matt's blog, they're going through a reasonable amount of due diligence. He writes at length about the exposures you're getting, the risks you're taking, and the fact that this is a back-of-the-envelope straw man, not actual investment advice.

In Covestor's case, it's a little less clear. The firm's "Moderate" portfolio consists of five well-run, cheap ETFs from BlackRock and Vanguard. It scores a "2" on Covestor's 5-point risk scale, suggesting it's almost as boring as you can get.

That risk-averse portfolio ends up being 15 percent in emerging markets equity and another 14 percent in developed international equity, with a 5 percent real estate kicker. That puts it surprisingly in line with Matt's take on what "aggressive" means.

Beginning to see the problem?

Putting together a diversified portfolio for pennies is almost literally child's play. I've taught my children's elementary school classmates how to do it, and these are kids who are mostly preoccupied with when we might get llamas into space. The rocket science isn't the portfolio construction; it's understanding what an individual investor actually needs.

Which gets me to the second set of emails from State Street. When asked what they were most looking for, here's what clients said:

Value

Everyone wants performance. Advice? Not so much. When then immediately asked where they thought their current providers failed them?

 

ETF DAILY DATA

A slew of iShares bond funds suffered outflows on Monday, March 2, but rising markets lifted total U.S.-listed ETF assets to $2.097 trillion.

'SPY,' 'GLD' and a slew of SPDR sector funds paced SSgA's issuer-leading outflows on Monday, March 2. But rising markets offset net outflows, lifting total U.S.-listed ETF assets to $2.097 trillion.

ETF.COM ANALYST BLOGS

By Olivier Ludwig

The world of ETFs is full of wonderful money-saving surprises.

By Howard Lee

An inside look at iShares’ new $75 million ‘smart beta’ bond ETF.

By Dave Nadig

With trillions of dollars of bonds yielding worse than nothing, should you be worried about your ETF?

By Elisabeth Kashner

Virtu’s mind-bending way to play oil market volatility is a fascinating glimpse into the world of ultra-sophisticated investors.