What’s An Index Worth?

By
October 17, 2012
Share:

Related ETFs

Ticker Fund name
SPYSPDR S&P 500
Related ETF Lists
Large Cap ETFs

Vanguard’s move to ditch MSCI is the latest sign of an indexing industry in transition.

 

[This article originally appeared on our sister site, IndexUniverse.eu.]

 

Vanguard’s recent decision to switch benchmark providers on half a trillion dollars of assets has thrown the indexing world into turmoil.

What’s an index worth to its provider? Put another way, how much should an investor expect to pay for the benchmark underlying an index-tracking fund?

Industry participants offer very different answers to this question, revealing tensions that go to the heart of how the asset management business operates.

A radical view of the indexing world, but one that’s apparently gaining traction, suggests that only a few large equity benchmarks have real brand value.

According to Steffen Scheuble of index provider Structured Solutions, maybe 10-20 indices worldwide fall into this category. He didn’t tell me what he thinks they are, but we can probably all come up with the likely names—S&P 500, MSCI World, Dow Jones industrial average, FTSE 100, Euro STOXX 50, Nikkei 225, DAX, CAC 40, plus a few more.

A couple of weeks ago, I’d have added the MSCI Emerging Markets index to the list, but Vanguard’s recent decision to ditch that benchmark for a lower-cost index offered by FTSE suggests the premium brand-name group might be shrinking.

Scheuble’s firm, and others of its type, offers to undercut the prices charged for brand-name indices by providing a slimmed-down service focusing on calculation and index maintenance only. This approach is bringing in a large volume of new business from cost-conscious product issuers, Scheuble says.

According to one index industry veteran, who spoke to me on condition of anonymity, a large indexing firm like BlackRock—and the investors in its funds—could easily save tens of millions of dollars a year in licensing fees by abandoning the majority of branded indices they pay for, internalizing the index design and outsourcing the index’s calculation and maintenance functions to low-cost providers. This basic service can apparently cost as little as a few thousand dollars a year per benchmark.

By contrast, says my industry contact, most index providers currently charge between 6 and 12 percent of an exchange-traded fund’s total expense ratio under the AUM-based licensing model that’s become standard across the industry over the last two decades. It’s that AUM-based fee scale that’s now under open attack.

And there are stand-out licensing fees, too; some falling well outside that 6-12 percent of total expense ratio range.

State Street Global Advisors’ $116 billion SPDR S&P 500 ETF (NYSEArca: SPY), the world’s biggest exchange-traded fund, pays a whopping 33 percent of its annual net expense ratio—3.1 basis points out of 9.45 basis points—to S&P Dow Jones for use of the 500-stock index, something that’s set in stone in the fund prospectus. That’s a cool $36 million a year in fees to the index provider from a single ETF.

So no wonder BlackRock has applied to the SEC to develop the benchmarks for its own funds.

 

ETF.COM CHANNELS

Want to learn more about smart-beta ETFs? Check out our smart-beta guide, essentials library and ETF screener!

ETF DAILY DATA

The AlphaDex financial fund 'FXO' led inflows on Tuesday, May 26, but net outflows and falling stocks pulled total U.S.-listed ETF assets down to $2.152 trillion.

A slew of redemptions from a number of iShares bond funds helped fuel that firm's issuer-leading outflows on Tuesday, May 26. Meanwhile, net outflows and a falling market dragged down total U.S.-listed ETF assets to $2.152 trillion.

ETF.COM ANALYST BLOGS

By Olly Ludwig

Yields will one day head higher, so is it time to get bond exposure outside the U.S.?

By Rachael Revesz

Stop dancing around the subject, call women ‘women’ and let’s be a more visible part of this industry.

By Olly Ludwig

It’s no secret that hedge funds love ETFs, but what’s less appreciated is that their love of ETFs will likely spell their demise.

By Olly Ludwig

Yes, bond yields are ticking higher these days, but it’s important to keep the whole yield-curve picture in mind.

ETF INDUSTRY PERSPECTIVE

By Nasdaq Global Indexes

Bond exposure or bond performance? Only defined maturity indexes provide the latter.

By Invesco PowerShares

Invesco PowerShares and Market Strategies International’s second annual survey provides vital insights about smart beta and ETFs overall.

By Invesco PowerShares

Investors are implementing smart-beta exchange-traded funds (ETFs) in their portfolios in a variety of ways and for different reasons.