Vanguard Gaining On iShares, State Street

By
Cinthia Murphy
September 10, 2013
Share:

Rankings of the top U.S. ETF issuers may look static, but looks are deceiving.

When it comes to the distribution of assets among U.S. ETF sponsors, there’s no questioning the dominance of the three ETF providers—iShares, State Street Global Advisors and Vanguard—who control more than 80 percent of the $1.5 trillion now invested in U.S.-listed ETFs. But that doesn’t mean rankings of ETF sponsors is in any way set in stone.

It’s true that those three firms have long been at the top of IndexUniverse’s “ETF League Table.” iShares alone managed more than a third of ETF assets in the U.S. market at the end of August—or some $588 billion—followed by State Street, with $337 billion in total assets under management, and Vanguard, with $289 billion.

But Vanguard has been slowly and consistently gaining on its competitors. In August alone, the Pennsylvania-based firm was the only ETF provider in the top five to end the month with positive net inflows. Vanguard’s $3.75 billion in new assets came even as the ETF market as a whole faced sizable redemptions—more than $17 billion that month.

State Street, for instance, bled a whopping $19.5 billion in August, or some 5.8 percent of its total assets, while iShares saw investors yank $4.33 billion from its funds in the same period.

Year-to-date, the picture isn’t all that different. While Vanguard has attracted some $37.5 billion in net new assets since the beginning of the year, State Street actually suffered net outflows of $11 billion in the first eight months of 2013—mostly tied to redemptions of more than $20 billion in the SPDR Gold Shares (GLD | A-100). What had been an $85 billion gap between State Street and Vanguard at the end of 2012 became a $48 billion gap as of the end of last month.

Meanwhile, iShares has raked in a relatively modest $6 billion year-to-date, but, due to market performance, the firm has seen its total assets grow by $30 billion to $588 billion.

Vanguard’s at-cost model—the more assets in each and every one of its funds, the cheaper each fund’s fees—is no doubt helping its asset-gathering. The firm is behind some of the cheapest ETFs in the market today. What’s more, those low costs extend to each and every one of its funds, and not just some of them, as is the case, for example, with iShares’ 10-fund lineup of dirt-cheap “Core” ETFs.

But brand loyalty to ETF providers could also be playing a role in how these asset breakdowns shake up, IndexUniverse President of ETF Analytics David Nadig recently suggested. Once a Vanguard client, always a Vanguard client.


ETF DAILY DATA

The oil funds 'XOP' and 'OIH' gathered money on Thursday, April 16, helping lift total U.S.-listed ETF assets to a record $2.158 trillion.

'SPY,' 'LNK' and 'XOP' paced SSgA's issuer-leader inflows on Thursday, April 16, as total U.S.-listed ETF assets reached a record $2.158 trillion.

ETF.COM ANALYST BLOGS

By Olivier Ludwig

If you’re puzzled by Israel’s relatively strong stock market performance, don’t forget you’re taking measure of a developed country.

By Olivier Ludwig

If only Fidelity could speak freely about all the positive things it does for investors.

By Dave Nadig

Last week’s minor information hiccup had huge implications.

By Dave Nadig

How Ric Edelman is reinventing the ‘new economy’ investing paradigm.