What Can Investors Learn From Goalkeepers?

November 10, 2008

How a behavioral phenomenon researchers call 'action bias' can affect portfolio decisions.


The financial turmoil that hit the global stock markets has scared investors away from stocks. Panicked about the fate of their savings, many investors liquidated their portfolios, thus causing a further decline in the market. Many financial planners and advisors are now recommending decreasing investors' exposure to equities.

Is this the right move? Should investors sell stocks when the market is going down?

A new article by a group of Israeli researchers sheds new light on this question from an unexpected direction—soccer games [Bar-Eli, Michael, Azar, Ofer H., Ritov, Ilana, Keidar-Levin, Yael and Schein, Galit (2005): "Action bias among elite soccer goalkeepers: The case of penalty kicks," forthcoming in: Journal of Economic Psychology].

The researchers examined a very unique situation in soccer games—penalty kicks. From a behavioral point of view, penalty kicks have several unique characteristics:

  • ln most cases, the penalty kick ends with a goal being scored, thus having a significant effect on the result of the game.
  • An experienced goalkeeper has faced many penalty kicks and thus is expected to know how to react to them.
  • From the moment of the kick, it takes 0.2-0.3 seconds until the ball reaches the goal. Thus, the goalkeeper cannot know in advance what will be the direction of the kick and must choose the direction of his jump based on his past experience.

As a result of these characteristics, a penalty kick is a type of a "natural experiment" in which it is possible to examine the choices made by the goalkeepers under uncertainty. Since soccer players' compensation is dependent on the performance of their team, the result of the goalkeeper's choice will not only affect the result of the particular game, but also the long-term prospects for himself and for his team.

The researchers examined 286 documented penalty kicks from games of top soccer teams. For each one of the penalty kicks, a group of three qualified referees was asked to determine: (1) the direction of the kick; (2) the direction of goalkeeper's jump.

The results are presented in Table 1.


Table 1: Kick Direction And Goalkeeper's Jump Direction


Kick Direction Jump Direction
Left 32.2%              Left 49.3%             
Center 28.7%              Center 6.3%             
Right 39.2%              Right 44.4%             



The left column shows that the directions of the kicks were almost uniformly distributed. About 1/3 of the kicks were aimed to each one of the directions (left, right or center of the goal).

On the other hand, the decisions of the goalkeepers (shown in the right column) are biased toward jumping to either the left or the right side of the goal. Only in just over 6% of the penalty kicks did the goalkeeper choose to stay in the center of the goal.

Were the decisions of the goalkeepers rational? To answer this question, the researchers examined the success rate of the goalkeepers to stop the penalty kicks. The results are presented in Table 2.



Trying to figure out alternatives ETFs? Use our alternatives ETFs channel, library and ETF screener!

Want to learn more about smart-beta ETFs? Check out our smart-beta guide, essentials library and ETF screener!


The broad-market 'SPY' and energy ETF 'XLE' were the biggest winners in terms of inflows on Thursday, Aug. 27.

The top three ETF issuers all saw net inflows into their products as the market surged on Thursday, Aug. 27.


By Dave Nadig

With many ETFs currently trading well off fair value, what’s an ETF investor to do? Don’t panic.

By Matt Hougan

Out-of-favor funds can bring attractive returns.

By Matt Hougan

New data from Charles Schwab show that the death of mutual funds is happening faster than we thought.

By Dave Nadig

Grab the popcorn. Precidian just doubled-down on its nontransparent active ETF proposal with the SEC this morning.


By John Del Vecchio

An index that goes long financially sound companies and shorts the ones with problematic balance sheets.

By Dan Draper

The nature of retirement is changing. How can investors adapt?

By Invesco PowerShares

A more in-depth look at the smart-beta survey's results.