Clark: Floating Debt Vs. High Yield

November 14, 2013

The good, the bad and the ugly of floating-rate debt.

This article is part of a regular series of thought-leadership pieces from some of the more-influential ETF strategists in the money management industry. Today's article features Sean Clark, chief investment officer of Philadelphia-based Clark Capital Management.

Historically low interest rates, accompanied by an unprecedented investor desire for income generation, have catapulted floating-rate debt instruments to take center stage in the search for yield.

The Morningstar Bank Loan category (floating-rate debt) had net flows of $38.6 billion year-to-date through July 31, making it the No. 1 segment in 2013. Clients are looking toward alternative income sources, and bank loans have clearly captured their attention.

With interest rates poised to rise as the Federal Reserve looks likely to begin unwinding the ultra-loose monetary policy put in place at the time of the financial crisis, this class of fixed income may help protect investors from the risks associated with a rise in bond yields.

But investors must understand the unique characteristics of the floating-rate debt asset class, and the impact the current market and economic environment will have on their potential for return.

I’ll examine the benefits and risks associated with floating rates and how the current climate has led to structural changes in many of the current issues.

The Good

Floating-rate loans have a variable interest rate that is typically tied to a money-market rate index such as Libor. They carry little rate risk since the interest rate of the issue periodically adjusts as rates change, and the debt is designed to keep pace with the overall market’s rate of interest.

During periods of economic growth and rising interest rates, floating rates can help investors diversify fixed-income allocations and protect against interest-rate risk. Unlike fixed-rate bonds whose prices decline when rates rise, floating-rate debt prices have been seen to remain relatively constant.

In today’s extremely low-rate environment, most high-grade bonds are returning a zero real return when interest is adjusted for inflation. Floating rates offer a higher yield and may help investors maintain a sufficient income stream that is protected against inflation.

1_Floating Rates


The Bad

The primary risk associated with this asset class is credit risk.

Issues are typically below investment grade, and firms issuing the debt are highly leveraged. They can’t be considered a conservative investment and, importantly, the majority of floating rates posted losses during the credit crisis.

Floating rates are not correlated to Treasurys, which can make them a beneficial component to a diversified portfolio. However, they are highly correlated to high-yield (junk) bonds.

The bank loan marketplace is typically a private one, unlike the public corporate bond market. Because the market is private, pricing is often opaque, and liquidity constraints may negatively impact returns.

With the amount of inflows into the category year-to-date, there are concerns that investors may be checking into Hotel California—you can check out any time you like, but you can never leave! At least not without paying a steep price if everyone heads for the door at the same time. On the other hand, junk bonds have greater liquidity and better price transparency.

The Ugly

Today’s floating rates carry some additional risks that must be considered.

The current high demand for floating rates has led to an increased frequency of new issues, many of which have more aggressive risk profiles than usual.

Most bank loans are now structured in a way that may seek to cap interest rates unless short-term rates rise to a predetermined point. As a result, investors may not see an increase in coupon payouts until money markets rise higher than is typically required for the issuer to make a change to the coupon rate.

Furthermore, many of the bonds are callable. If an issuer redeems a bond before maturity, the investor could miss a significant portion of the rate increase. In such a scenario, the investor may never see the benefits of holding on to floating rates in a rising rate environment.

Investment Considerations

Floating-rate funds are included in the investment universe for Clark Capital’s Navigator Fixed Income Total Return strategy. Our portfolio managers consistently weigh the benefits and the risks associated with investing in this asset class.

Up until this point, we have used high-yield bonds as the primary low-quality debt investment vehicle in the strategy. If we identify benefits that floating rates will provide above and beyond high yields, such as providing a cushion against rising rates or enhancing the risk profile of the overall portfolio, we would consider an investment in the floating-rate space.

Clark Capital Management Group is an independent investment advisory firm providing institutional-quality investment solutions to individual investors, corporations, foundations, and retirement plans. Clark Capital was founded in 1986 and has been entrusted with approximately $3 billion in assets.

For more information about Clark, contact Advisor Support at 800-766-2264 or [email protected].



Find your next ETF

Reset All